Lots of losers and a few winners

March 1, 2020

Lots of losers and a few winners

March 1, 2020
The result is a dynamic market and that picture is almost the same all over the world.

At the time of writing this column I should have been on the train from Zermatt to Geneva to catch a plane to Amsterdam. Up and down to address the International Top Media Convention, which 3Rivers has been organizing together with Broadcast Magazine for years.

We would be talking about the great time we have in the audiovisual media. The dynamics have never been greater: the impetus that direct-to-consumer activities give to our industry is unparalleled. After all, at least $ 20 billion extra is spent worldwide on content production, especially scripted programming. Market leader Netflix and a long list of other SVOD operators are investing large sums in brand new productions of a high level. Broadcasters are also showing signs of defending their position by investing more in local programming. Where in the past roughly 1/3 of the program budget was spent on international series, much more is now invested in local programming. Not only local drama, but also entertainment and factual shows are in great demand. The result is a dynamic market and that picture is almost the same all over the world.

At the IMTC we would talk about this fantastic development. Netflix manager Lina Brouneus would talk about the development that Netflix is ​​going through. Where does the company come from in its content strategy and, above all, where is it going in the coming years. Markus Schaeffer, CEO of All3 Media in Germany and Christophe Thoral, CEO of Lagardère, would be present to share their vision on the Dutch TV production market. After all, their companies own IDTV and Skyhigh TV respectively and have invested years ago in the Netherlands. At the same time, they would also discuss specific developments in their own countries: the steps that the French government is taking to force international players to invest maximally in the French market (yes, the exception Francaise from the film world is also entering TV production. ) and the fundamental change in the German scripted market, which was always so conventionally and purely aimed at Germany and now also reaches an international audience with productions like Dark and Deutschland 1983.

The highlight of the evening would be Marco Bassetti, who will lead the largest TV production company in the world this year. After all, Banijay (crammed with ex-Endemol managers) will take over Endemol Shine if the European Commission approves. This creates the largest TV production company in the world with a turnover of almost 3 billion euros. Discussion leader Rick Nieman would interview him extensively about how he will implement the integration of these companies.

Would. Because we all know it by now, Corona is ending the event. The studio in the Hallen will remain empty tonight. Just like so many other studios will be vacant in the coming months. Emptiness reigns: all developments that we would discuss tonight are on hold. 2020 seems to be a written off year for all TV production companies, the tide can turn that quickly.

You might also be interested in these articles...

The Future of Media

When we launched one of the first European MCN's 15 years ago, the narrative was simple: it was YouTube versus Linear TV. We were the disruptors, and broadcast TV became traditional media.

But looking at the industry today, that era feels like a lifetime ago. We've moved from a 'two-horse race' to a total fragmentation of attention. In the next few minutes I'll talk you through that evolution, and share why I believe the biggest disruption is actually yet to come.

The Battle for the Eyeballs (2016-2017)

Fast forward to 2016, we entered a new battle of attention; the Creator Economy. Suddenly, it wasn't just YouTube, but also Instagram, Snapchat, and a newcomer called Musical.ly (later TikTok) marked the start of platform cannibalization. TikTok and Instagram weren't just eating into the remaining linear TV time; they were fighting YouTube for every second of the youth's attention. YouTube’s monopoly on digital video was over, while older audiences were finally discovering YouTube, the kids were moving toward hyper-short-form.

This was the moment 'traditional' YouTube videos (the 10-to-20-minute formats) were suddenly seen as 'Long-form.' The definition of patience was definitely changing. And not just among the younger demographic.

Convergence

Today, we see a fascinating (and perhaps slightly alarming) trend: Platform Convergence. Every platform is starting to look exactly like its competitor. YouTube has Shorts, Instagram has Reels, TikTok is pushing into longform, Netflix is experimenting with short clips and Spotify is actively pushing video content. Everyone is fighting for the same 'scroll.'

Simultaneously, the high-end VOD market, with Netflix, HBO, Disney+, Prime Video and Apple TV exploded, alongside the renaissance of audio through podcasts and audiobooks. We are consuming more content than ever before in human history, but it is more fragmented than we could ever imagine just one decade ago.

This leads us to a question we frequently discuss at 3Rivers: (How) can traditional media companies keep up with this velocity?

If broadcasters and production houses are still struggling with a 'Streaming First' mindset, how will they survive this “attention Economy” reality? Take the BBC, for example. Just recently, they announced a landmark partnership with YouTube to produce bespoke, original programming specifically for the platform. Not just clips, but full shows designed for a YouTube-native audience.

When the world's leading public broadcaster admits they can no longer reach the next generation through their own front door, you know the gatekeeper era is officially over. They aren't just 'posting' on YouTube anymore; they are building for it. And it’s not just about content; it’s about infrastructure...

In the US, YouTube is effectively becoming the new 'Cable Company.' Through YouTube TV, they are bundling over 100 linear channels, and by poaching the NFL Sunday Ticket from traditional satellite TV, they’ve secured the ultimate 'must-have' content. They aren't just competing with broadcasters anymore; they are replacing the entire distribution chain.

And we haven't even seen the full storm yet. We are looking at:

  • Live Shopping: Platforms like Whatnot and TikTok Shop are turning entertainment directly into commerce.
  • And Micro-Dramas: Apps like ReelShort or PineDrama (Also TikTok Owned) are producing professionally produced fiction in 1-minute vertical episodes.

These are not just experiments. The micro-drama industry alone is projected to reach $26 billion in annual revenue by 2030. We are seeing startups in this space valued at hundreds of millions of dollars before they even have a full library.

So If YouTube is the new cable company, Netflix is not slowing down, TikTok stars are the new Hollywood studios and drama is shortened to 1 minute vertical content... then where does that leave the traditional industry? That’s the question I’ll be tackling this year for us and our clients. A fascinating puzzle, and I’m enjoying every piece of it.

READ MORE

Production Value

In December, the international creative community gathers in London to take the temperature of the industry: debating trends, forging partnerships, and hunting for the next big format. In recent years, a new fixture has joined the global circuit of media markets: Content London. C21, once primarily a publisher, now increasingly a heavyweight conference organizer, is steadily tightening its grip on streamers, producers, and broadcasters.

The British creative sector, meanwhile, has reason to celebrate. In 2003, a landmark change in legislation granted producers ownership of the IP they create. It transformed the industry. Since then, the UK’s creative economy has expanded at remarkable speed. This year alone, more than two billion £ worth of formats, finished program sales (these days more often counted as library sales), and consumer products will leave the country. For the UK, the United States has long been a natural export market (the absence of a language barrier helps) and nearly half of all international sales continue to flow across the Atlantic.

This success is anything but accidental. Investors are lining up to back creative talent, the government actively supports the production ecosystem, and the talent pool seems endlessly replenished. More than forty new production companies launch each year, even as the domestic market stagnates. The UK advertising market may be under pressure, but the country’s robust export pipeline more than compensates. I’ve worked in this sector for around fifteen years, and its consistent level of creative excellence never ceases to impress.

The framework may have been shaped by government policy, but it is creative entrepreneurs who continue to push the industry forward. Take Richard McKerrow, founder of Love Productions and the mind behind The Great British Bake Off. Or Stephen Lambert, creator of Gogglebox and Undercover Boss and founder of Studio Lambert. Lambert has built a powerhouse team capable of elevating even externally conceived IP, The Traitors being the most striking example, to extraordinary global success. Each year brings a new wave of talent with ideas that spark fresh energy across the industry.

Driving it all is the British audience itself: curious, loyal, and accustomed to high-quality homegrown programming. Every genre thrives; from soaps (yes, Coronation Street is still going strong) to prestige drama, from factual to entertainment. Anyone wanting to understand what true creative entrepreneurship looks like need only spend some time in the capital of the audiovisual world.

Skeptics might point to turbulence: the challenges at the BBC and Channel 4, Sky’s bid for ITV, or the looming saturation of the streaming market. The rules of the audiovisual landscape are indeed being rewritten. But the British creative engine shows little sign of slowing. It continues to do what it has always done best: turn ideas into global successes.

READ MORE

Small, Bigger, Biggest

Do you remember that video from 2006 featuring YouTube founders Chad Hurley and Steve Chen? The two young men addressed the 'YouTube Community' with promises of continued innovation and product development. But after just two and a half minutes, they could no longer keep a straight face. They had just sold their barely 18-month-old, loss-making company to Google for a staggering 1.65 billion dollars.

At the time, many thought Google had lost its mind for paying such an astronomical amount for a fledgling startup. But it quickly became clear that the tech giant had placed a calculated bet. The modest YouTube maintained its position as the market leader in online video, while Google's own platform never gained traction. The team at Google had already recognized that video would become the next killer application on the Internet. Instead of competing, they acquired the persistent rival that was standing in their way, regardless of the cost. The rest is history. According to social media expert Jonatan de Boer, YouTube now generates over 36 billion dollars in annual revenue.

Today, YouTube is unquestionably the largest video platform in the world. Monthly views are measured in the trillions, and the number of active channels approaches 5 million. What stands out is that, according to a recent report by Evan Shapiro, nearly 95 percent of all views come from just the top 10 channels. What began as a platform for short-form, user-generated content is now evolving into a wide-reaching video ecosystem. And increasingly, major media companies are embracing it.

Just a decade ago, traditional broadcasters were extremely hesitant to publish content on YouTube. The Dutch public broadcaster NPO offers a striking example. Acting under the leadership of then-chairman Henk Hagoort, the organization tightly controlled content distribution and explicitly forbade its affiliated broadcasters from using YouTube.

The situation today could not be more different. YouTube is now seen as an ideal platform to promote television programs. An additional reason has emerged as well. YouTube attracts a predominantly younger audience, which gives media companies a valuable opportunity to connect with a harder-to-reach demographic.

Channel 4 in the United Kingdom was among the first broadcasters to recognize the platform’s potential. After a test phase, they decided last year to start publishing long-form content on YouTube. They were also allowed to manage advertising on their Channel 4 YouTube page themselves, with a share of the revenue naturally going to Google.

This created a win-win situation. The broadcaster gained additional reach. YouTube gained more compelling content for its viewers. And both parties benefited from the resulting revenue. YouTube is now often watched on television screens, competes directly with Netflix, and even commands more viewing time in the United States, with 12 percent compared to Netflix’s 7.5 percent. ITV has already followed with a similar deal, and it seems inevitable that others will join. All of this continues to strengthen YouTube's already dominant position: in just 20 years, the once awkward underdog has grown into a mighty media giant.

READ MORE